The Witch’s Grave

Posted: 06.23.2024 | Updated: 04.30.2025

The Old City Cemetery in Tallahassee is home to an unusually extravagant gravestone. The obelisk on the grave of Elizabeth Budd-Graham, also known as Bessie, towers above the rest of the graves in the cemetery.

The walled-off stone tower commands attention and attracts onlookers who leave flowers and coins, hoping to make a wish.

But who was Bessie? And why does she have a massive grave fit for a princess?

Curious about the ghostly tales that haunt the witch’s grave? Join Tampa Terrors and hear the stories come alive.

Who Was Bessie The Tallahassee Witch?

In the quiet Old City Cemetery of Tallahassee lies a grave that continues to puzzle and intrigue both locals and ghost hunters alike.

It belongs to Elizabeth Budd-Graham, a woman better known by the nickname passed down through legend—Bessie the Tallahassee Witch. Her life was short, but what she left behind has sparked eerie questions for over a century.

Known today as “the Florida witch’s grave,” her final resting place stands out in a haunting way. The witch tombstone is elaborate, towering, and draped in gothic beauty, unlike the simpler markers around it.

But it’s the poetic epitaph carved into her stone that truly raises eyebrows. What message did she leave behind, and why?

Some say her grave has unusual energy. Others swear it’s one of the most haunted places in Florida. Was she really a witch? Or was Bessie just a misunderstood woman who became part of Tallahassee’s haunted folklore?

Read more to find out the truth behind the legend of Bessie, the woman whose grave still whispers through the moss-covered cemetery paths.

 The Tallahassee Witch

According to local folklore, Bessie was a witch, which is why her gravestone is known as the Florida Witch’s Grave. The exorbitant centerpiece is engraved with her name, birthday, and information about her family.

However, what leads many to believe she was a witch is the excerpt from one of Edgar Allen Poe’s poems, Lenore, which seemingly references common themes in witchcraft. There’s also the fact that Bessie was only 23 years old when she died, and yet she has the biggest grave in the graveyard.

Many defend Bessie, saying she was a “white witch,” meaning she cast spells with love and happiness in mind. Others say Bessie wasn’t a witch at all, but a very good Christian woman who was well-loved by her family and friends.

Whatever the real story was, her grave attracts hundreds of visitors every year, including fellow “witches” who perform rituals and cast spells at her grave. Some have even seen ghosts at Bessie’s grave at night, most commonly the ghost of a young woman sobbing at her grave.

The Old City Cemetery

Bessie is buried at Tallahassee’s Old City Cemetery, the city’s first public graveyard. The people buried at the cemetery are a sample of Tallahassee society in the 19th century.

There are politicians, slaves, business owners, war heroes, workers, and victims of yellow fever. Much of the graveyard is segregated. White people were buried on the east side, while Blacks, both enslaved and freedmen, were buried on the west side.

The cemetery was established in 1829 on land previously used for raising livestock. In 1840, the city of Tallahassee took over the cemetery as a yellow fever epidemic struck the city.

They began laying out graves en masse to meet the demand for space. After the epidemic passed, many of Tallahassee’s most influential people were buried at the Old City Cemetery.

At the south end of the graveyard, along Martin Luther Jr. Boulevard, lies the witch’s tombstone. The obelisk at the center of Bessie’s grave is about seven feet tall. The grave is bounded by a short stone wall, about a foot tall. Within the wall are a few stone vases.

Bessie the Witch?

The rumors of Bessie’s “witchiness” stem solely from her grave. Many of the townsfolk couldn’t believe that someone who died so young would be gifted such an extraordinary tombstone. She was only 23 when she died, so rumors spread that she bewitched a rich man into marrying her.

Another interesting note about the witch’s tombstone is that it faces west, while the rest of the graves face to the east, in a blatant act of defiance against Christian tradition.

What really drove people to believe Bessie was a witch was the poem from Edgar Allen Poe, which supposedly makes a few references to witchcraft.

“Broken is the golden bowl” refers to the witch’s cauldron, which Bessie has broken since she passed away. “A saintly soul floats on the Stygian River” refers to the River Styx, which a witch cannot cross in death.

If she is a witch, Bessie’s spirit will remain in limbo in the afterlife. “The queenliest dead” refers to witches being the “Queens of the Dead.” Finally, “the doubly dead” is a nod to the fact that witches must be killed twice.

Even though no evidence points to Bessie being a witch, the rumors persist. They say she could have been a white witch who casts spells for good. Even so, her grave attracts many fellow witches to this day.

They practice rituals, cast spells, and come to Bessie to ask her spirit for help. Some say that a ghost even hangs around Bessie’s grave. The spirit of a young woman has been seen sobbing in front of the gravesite.

The Witch’s Tombstone

Skeptics say that Bessie was deeply loved by her husband and the community, and much of the “evidence” pointing toward Bessie being a witch can be easily explained. As for the ornate gravestone, Bessie’s husband was quite rich.

Mr. John A Graham was a local lumber magnate, cattleman, and real estate developer. He had the money to splurge on a grave for his beloved wife. The gravestone itself is riddled with Christian imagery.

The cross inside the crown expresses their Christian values and is a symbol often used in Freemasonry. Interestingly enough, her husband was, in fact, a Mason.

Skeptics have yet to debunk the poem’s true meaning. It could just be a poem, after all. Whereas today, music is the most common medium for self-expression, Victorian-era socialites looked to poetry to express themselves.

Like the Freemasons, witches keep their activities a secret. So, only real witches may know the truth about Bessie. Still, the witchcraft, rituals, and spellcasting around her grave continue, as do the ghost sightings.

A visit to the Florida Witch’s Grave reveals coins, seashells, and other mementos left atop her grave ornaments as offerings to Bessie for good luck.

Learn more about the haunted history of Florida

Whether she was truly a white witch or just a misunderstood soul, Elizabeth Budd-Graham’s final resting place continues to draw curiosity, mystery, and whispers from beyond the grave.

Known far and wide as “the Florida witch’s grave,” her ornate witch tombstone stands out like a spell among the simple stones that surround it, captivating tourists, ghost hunters, and even practicing witches who leave behind tokens, flowers, and candles.

Many who visit claim to see the ghost of a woman, her sobs echoing through the mossy cemetery, kneeling before the grave, cloaked in sorrow. Is it the Tallahassee Witch herself? Or someone else tied to her tragic tale?

The site has earned its place among the most chilling haunted places in Florida, and her story continues to live on in legend, inked in stone and shadow.

As you all know, the Sunshine State isn’t all sunshine and rainbows. Check out Annie Lytle Elementary School, known to locals as the Devil’s School. This abandoned school was closed down in the 1960s and was rumored to be the home to a cannibalistic principal, a murderous janitor, and a Satanic cult.

You can also grab a beer at the Last Resort in Port Orange, the bar where serial killer Aileen Wournos had her last beer. After killing seven men, Aileen was finally apprehended after ordering her last brew at the Last Resort.

There’s a whole lot more to discover! Go and read the most haunted places in Florida! If you’re ready to hear this eerie tale firsthand, book a ghost tour with Tampa Terrors.

Craving more ghost stories and haunted history? Check out our blog, and don’t forget to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok for your daily dose of spooky content.

Sources:

1. https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlwelsh/4334971919
2. https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-grave-of-elizabeth-buddgraham-tallahassee-florida
3. https://visittallahassee.com/partners/old-city-cemetery/
4. https://www.tallyguide.com/blog/the-double-dead-white-witch-of-tallahassee-florida
5. https://skepticalinquirer.org/newsletter/tallahassees-witchs-grave/